On one day, I gave the direct instruction to the Year 12 group. They were learning rendering skills to apply to their design developments.
On the next day, the group of 6 Year 12 students taught these skills to a Year 10 class over a double period.
This is the direct instruction given to the Year 12 students in regard to hard to do the rendering techniques that they were going to teach and use themselves.
This is the focus instruction on what they should concentrate on with the Year 10 class.
I got them to focus mainly on a simple box shape, use 3 tones, leave a white Y on the front corners and put a shadow on the dark side.
Here is some of the ongoing lesson where the Year 12 boys were working with the Year 10 class on their rendering skills.
Here are some photographs taken during the session, showing the Year 12 students working closely with the Year 10 class.
Lesson Topic :- Rendering
Level 2 - Development of concept ideas - AS91342
Year Group :- Year 12
The Year 12 group with transfer their rendering skills onto a Year 10 class.
The question is whether they understand how to do something any better by teaching someone else how to do it.
Links with the New Zealand Curriculum
Curriculum Level: 7
Learning Area: Technology
Strand: Design and Visual Communication
Achievement Objective: Outcome development and evaluation
Critically analyse their own and others’ outcomes and evaluative practices to inform the development of ideas for feasible outcomes. Undertake a critical evaluation that is informed by ongoing experimentation and functional modelling, stakeholder feedback, and trialling in the physical and social environments. Use the information gained to select, justify, and develop an outcome. Evaluate this outcome’s fitness for purpose against the brief. Justify the evaluation, using feedback from stakeholders and demonstrating a critical understanding of the issue.
Achievement Standard: AS91342
The Year 12 students have done a lot of work on drawing in 3D.
We have done some work on rendering in past lessons.
The Year 10 students have done some work on 3D sketching using the isometric grids - so a brief reminder will be necessary for this but they should know enough.
Talking to the Year 10 group about what they thought of being taught by the Year 12 students instead of the class teacher.
Did they listen more?
Did they understand the task any better?
Reflection and Analysis
Monday 12th January
Session with the first group of Year 12 students - Period 1 and 2
What went well?
Splitting the skills up into small chunks for them to see then practice worked well as they could see what to do in small steps instead of forgetting most of a longer demonstration.
This also modelled to them how to present this content to the Year 10 class when they see them.
They practiced their skills more than once each time which was a good step forward.
They listened well and had a really good try at each step that I showed them today so the quality of their work was of a good standard.
They were keen to try the different media that were on offer for the rendering skills.
What needs work?
Getting them to come backwards and forwards to the front of the room, or around one table for small demonstrations is always a struggle as they moan and complain each time I want them to come together. Maybe doing the demos on the big screen with the drawing board projector would have worked better as they could have stayed where they were.
Tuesday 13th June
Double period with the Year 12 group teaching the Year 10 students
What went well?
The Year 10 students responded very well to the Year 12 group teaching them. They listened very well and were very respectful to the boys. They tried really hard with the skills they were being taught and made a good job of them.
The group of Year 12 boys did a good job of working through the steps in the skills that they were demonstrating.
It was good to see them being so supportive of the Year 10 students as they were working, helping them improve, and making supportive comments and judgments.
The boys ended up working in pairs for the activity today so their group size was a little bigger than planned but they felt more confident doing it this way so it worked out well in the end.
You could see the boys enthusiasm and confidence grow as the session progressed and some of them ended up doing a little roaming of the room seeing what other groups were doing too.
What needs work?
I should have let the Year 10 students know before hand what was going on, especially in regards to getting into groups. They were quite “precious” about what group they were working in.
We had a couple of no shows of the year 12 group so a couple of them were last minute inclusions. I thought they did well in spite of this though.
The boys were very shy about doing the teaching and were EXTREMELY shy about being recorded, so some of the recording s are lacking heads.
Feedback from the Year 12 Group